Sunday Supper is an Amazon Associate and may receive compensation for purchases made through affiliate links.
Garlicky, buttery, and oh-so-crispy, our Garlic Butter Creamer Potatoes make a delicious side dish for every meal from beef to chicken.
The best part is that these crispy roasted potatoes only take minutes to prepare and are perfect for a quick and easy weeknight meal. My kids LOVE these garlic butter roasted potatoes!
These sweet creamer potatoes, seasoned to perfection and baked in a skillet, are a favorite for Sunday supper and holiday recipes!
Jump to:
Best Small Potatoes Recipe
These potatoes are a perfect addition to a steak dinner or a holiday prime rib. You might even like them better than the beef! In fact… we know you will! They are that good.
The best part is, that garlic butter potatoes are super easy to prepare: just halve the potatoes, season them, and roast. Done!
This recipe was so easy to prepare and came out so good!
Donna on Pinterest
Small Potatoes Recipe Ingredients
- garlic powder
- butter
- Maldon sea salt or sea salt of your choice
- black pepper
- creamer potatoes
- fresh parsley
How to Cook Creamer Potatoes
- Preheat the oven to 425°F. Cut creamer potatoes into halves and add them to a bowl.
- Sprinkle garlic powder, melted butter, Maldon sea salt or sea salt of your choice, and black pepper on the potatoes.
- Mix potatoes with seasoning until fully coated.
- Add seasoned creamer potatoes to an oven-ready cast iron skillet. Spread out evenly. Sprinkle with fresh parsley if desired.
- Roast for approximately 1 hour for crispy potatoes. Enjoy!
Creamer Potatoes Recipe Tips
- Make sure the potatoes are spread out on the baking sheet or skillet so they cook evenly.
- Do not flip them. Let them sit as they roast – this ensures the crispiest garlic butter potatoes!
- Toss well to evenly coat them with the garlic butter sauce. You want that delicious sauce all over them. Trust me!
Small Potatoes Recipes FAQs
They are a special variety of potatoes that are grown to be small! In fact, they are also called baby potatoes. They come in a variety of colors similar to fingerling potatoes and cook quickly thanks to their tiny size. What we love most about these baby potatoes is that they are always so smooth and delicious – creamer is a good name for them, for how creamy they are!
There’s no need to peel creamer potatoes! The skin is soft and smooth, and when you’re making garlic butter potatoes roasted in the oven, it gives them that perfect crisp.
Best Small Potato Recipes
- Easy Foil Pack Potatoes – you can make these on the grill or in the oven!
- Smothered Potatoes and Sausage – made in a Dutch Oven!
- Grilled Potatoes
- Potatoes and Chorizo
- Grilled Potatoes Recipe
You can use creamer potatoes for all kinds of dishes, from Zuppa Toscano, to stew, to potato salad. If you like your mashed potatoes with a little skin left in, baby potatoes are perfect to use because the skin is so soft!
Best Way to Store Small Potatoes
- Make sure your little potatoes are free of any blemishes; those will not last as long.
- Add them to a mesh or paper bag, or a cardboard box, so they can breathe well. Do not store them in plastic bags.
- Store in a cool location for best results, but do not store potatoes in the fridge.
- Don’t wash your baby potatoes until you’re ready to cook with them, and make sure not to store them with other vegetables or fruit.
Uncooked garlic butter potatoes last for about 2 weeks when stored correctly.
📌 Pin it for later!
Did you enjoy this page? Save it on Pinterest for later!📋 Recipe
Garlic Butter Small Potatoes Recipe
Equipment
- Skillet
Ingredients
- 1 Tbsp. garlic powder
- 4 Tbsp. butter
- 2 pinches Maldon sea salt
- 2 pinches black pepper
- 24 oz. creamer potatoes sold as 1 package
- fresh parsley optional, to taste
Instructions
- Preheat oven to 425°F. Cut creamer potatoes into halves and add them to a bowl.
- Sprinkle 1 Tbsp. garlic powder, 4 Tbsp. melted butter, 2 pinches Maldon sea salt, and 2 pinches black pepper on the potatoes.
- Mix potatoes with seasoning until fully coated.
- Add seasoned creamer potatoes to an oven-ready cast iron skillet. Spread out evenly. Sprinkle with fresh parsley if desired.
- Roast for approximately 1 hour for crispy potatoes. Enjoy!
Video
Notes
- Make sure the potatoes are spread out on the baking sheet or skillet so they cook evenly.
- Do not flip them. Let them sit as they roast – this ensures the crispiest baby potatoes!
- Toss well to evenly coat them with the garlic butter sauce. You want that delicious sauce all over those potatoes. Trust me!
- Try seasoning potatoes with our Garlic Butter Sauce!
Love the recipe
Thanks so much, Tammy!
I am unsure how to rate this recipe. The flavor was so promising but mine were already overbrowned when I checked them after 40 minutes at only 400F. I will definitely make them again but will begin checking after 25 minutes at 400F. Thanks!
Thank you Joan! We haven’t experienced that but all ovens are different, so checking after 25 minutes sounds like a great plan. We’re glad you enjoyed them!
I baked mine for 45 minutes at 400 so you’re right about ovens being different. They were delicious. I combined them to make a ground beef hash.
That sounds delicious, Clark! Thank you for your comment – we’re so glad you tried them!